Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- devel:blueprints:ipdevpoll [2008/12/11 09:09] – Add list of suggested plugins thomaska
+++ devel:blueprints:ipdevpoll [2012/05/07 11:26] (current) – fix url morten
@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 ====== ipdevpoll design specification ======
+**This page is currently being updated to match whats being developed. Dont trust this stuff just yet :-)**
 ===== Introduction =====
 //ipdevpoll// is the planned replacement for getDeviceData, becoming the third generation SNMP polling framework for NAV.  This page will lay out the various design ideas and specifications for the new program.
@@ Line 7: / Line 10: @@
   * Asynchronous SNMP polling, built with [[http://twistedmatrix.com/trac/|Twisted]] and [[http://twistedsnmp.sourceforge.net/|TwistedSNMP]]
   * Plugin based architecture
-  * Data persistence based on Twisted aDBI? (FIXME)
 ==== Core application ====
-The gDD core application has the following basic tasks:
+The core application has the following basic tasks:
   * Schedule executing of jobs
-  * Execute plugins contained in job in correct order
+  * Execute plug-ins contained in job in correct order
-  * Handle rescheduling when a plugin signals that previous state has been invalidated
+  * Provide data persistence to plug-ins
-  * Provide data persistence to plugins
-Scheduling of jobs instead of individual plugins has been chosen to simplify the application due to the high level of dependency between some of the plugins. Each job defined in the the gDD configuration defines a set of plugins that are to be run at a given interval. The scheduling of these intervals is handled using Twisted's built in scheduling mechanisms.
+Jobs are a group of plug-ins run in a specified order, and scheduled at a specified time interval. The scheduling is handled by Twisted.
+NAV provide two jobs in the default configuration, ''Inventory'' and ''Logging''.
+These provide a sane order for the plug-ins to run. The user may specify their own jobs and schedules in ''jobs.conf''. The configuration files used by ipdevpoll follows the syntax
+demanded by the python ConfigParser-module.
+\\
+\\
+Example jobs.conf
+<code ini>
+[inventory]
+interval: 60s
+plugins:
+ typeoid
+ dnsname
+ interfaces
+ vlan
+ prefix
+</code>
-The previous version of gDD determined plugin execution order based on numeric values assigned to each plugin, this implies that every plugin must know about the value of all other plugins to be sure that it gets executed before and/or after relevant plugins. To avoid this error prone method of ordering using a simple dependence system between plugins has been suggested. Each plugin needs to know which plugins need to run before itself. This data can be used to do a topological sort based on the dependence arcs between plugins.
+One advantage of this way of doing things is easy deployment of several ipdevpolld-processes, either on the same host or distributed over several machines.
-FIXME data persistence/containers
+==== Data ====
+Data is provided through the use of shadow-classes of django-models. Plugins never write django-objects directly. This is handled by the job the plugin runs in at the end of each job.
+Shadow-classes are created in ''nav.ipdevpoll.shadows''
+\\
+Example shadowclass specification
+<code python>
+class Interface(Shadow):
+    __shadowclass__ = manage.Interface
+    __lookups__ = [('netbox', 'ifname'), ('netbox', 'ifindex')]
+</code>
+The Shadow-class has two important attributes. ''<nowiki>__shadowclass__</nowiki>'' specifies
+which django model to mimic. This will make any instances of the shadowclass
+answers to the same attributes as the django model. When a property is changed
+on the shadowclass, the class will set it state to touched. This is needed for
+determining wheter to update an object or not at the end of a run. To lookup
+existing objects in the database the storage system first tries the primary key
+field on the object. If the PK is None, the ''<nowiki>__lookup__</nowiki>''-attribute is used
+for the checking. The ''<nowiki>__lookup__</nowiki>'' attribute is a list of strings and tuples.
+Tuples specifies combined lookups, while strings specifies single field
+lookups. The different lookups are tried in the order they are defined in the
+list. If we look at the example above, it will first try to get an existing
+object with only the ''interface.id''-field. If its unavailable it tries the
+first object in the lookup-list, a combined search for objects matching both
+the ''netbox'' and ''ifname'' properties on the shadow instance. If
+unsuccessful it goes on to the next lookup field.
+There are two major "gotcha"s here. First of, the lookups must be unique. If
+multiple rows are returned an exception is raised. The second is primary key
+lookups where the primary key is not an AutoField; if no rows are found when
+using non-AutoField primary keys, a new object is created. If the field is an
+AutoField however, and no rows are returned, an exception is raised.
+Deletion of objects in the database is done if the shadowobject has its
+''delete''-property set to True.
+Once the job is done the storage routine is called. The storage system then parses all
+the shadow objects contained in ''job_handler.container'' and make s sure all foreignkeys needed for the storing
+an instance are saved before the object it self.
 ==== Plugins ====
@@ Line 30: / Line 87: @@
 Installed plugins should be specified as a simple list of module names to import in string form (much like django's INSTALLED_APPS setting). During import each plugin will be responsible for registering itself by calling gdd.plugins.register(<class>), this will add the plugin to a global list of plugins which will be topologically sorted once the plugin list has been processed.
-Each plugin will be called in order and must itself determine if the netbox in question is of instrest (ie. dues it support the mibs that the plugin knows about, does the netbox vendor match those supported by the plugin...). Once this is decided the plugin can either pass or start collecting more SNMP data and populate the data persistence store and/or modify the allready there (ie. vendor specific interpretations). Once all plugins have run gDD must ensure that the updated data is stored to the database.
+Each plugin will be called in order and must itself determine if the netbox in question is of instrest (ie. dues it support the mibs that the plugin knows about, does the netbox vendor match those supported by the plugin...). Once this is decided the plugin can either pass or start collecting more SNMP data and populate the data persistence store and/or modify the already there (ie. vendor specific interpretations). Once all plugins have run gDD must ensure that the updated data is stored to the database.
 To keep the plugin directory somewhat organized the following organization has been proposed:
@@ Line 46: / Line 103: @@
       - arp.py
       - ...
+===== New plugin design proposal =====
+Plugins should be divided into their respective responsibilities. Each plugin should be its own python module
+with a defined handler-class sub-classed from the nav.ipdevpoll.Plugin-class. The handler should only deal with
+storing the information to the database and logic to determine if vendor-specific collections methods should be used.
+Each plugin should supply its own test-suite in a folder called test withing the plugin module. Every plugin should
+prefer to use the MIB-2 standard mibs for collecting information, falling back to vendor specific mibs.
+To maximize the amount of easily testable code, all parsing logic should be extracted into their own methods and not
+be entangled into the collection process (methods that returns deferred objects). Remember to call the processing
+methods asynchronously as well.
+  /nav/ipdevpoll/plugins
+    - /iftable
+      - iftable.py
+      - test_iftable.py
+      - collector.py
+      - /vendor
+        - cisco.py
+        - test_cisco.py
+        - alcatel.py
+        - test_alcatel.py
+        - ..
+Example plugin:
+<code python>
+from nav.ipdevpoll import Plugin
+from nav.ipdevpoll.plugins.vlan import collector
+class Vlan(Plugin):
+    def __init__(self, *args, **kwargs):
+        """
+        Initialize the plugin
+        """
+        Plugin.__init__(self, *args, **kwargs)
+        self.deferred = defer.Deferred()
+    def handle(self):
+        """
+        This is the entry point for the plugin.
+        """
+        self.logger.debug("Collecting VLAN information")
+        collector.collect(self.job_handler.agent)
+        return self.deferred
+    def process_result(self, result):
+        """
+        Standard processing method for all plugins.
+        The collections methods should provide data
+        in the same format to this method.
+        """
+        if not result:
+            self.logger.debug(
+                "No VLAN information found using MIB-2 MIBS.\
+                 Trying vendor specific collection")
+            # Try vendor specific methods
+        else:
+            self.logger.debug("Found %s VLANs. Processing." % len(result))
+            for ifIndex, vlan in result:
+                # Store the information to database or similar
+                pass
+            # Plugin-run finished. Exit.
+            self.deferred.callback(True)
+            return result
+</code>
 === Suggested log plugins ===
-  - ARP
+  * ARP
-  - CAM (currently in getBoksMacs)
+  * CAM (currently in getBoksMacs)
-  - RRD stats (currently provided by crikect)
+  * RRD stats (currently provided by cricket)
-  - ModuleMon replacement
 === Suggested inventory plugins ===
-  - Type OID
+  * Type OID
-  - DNS
+  * DNS
-  - Interface (if-MIB)
+  * Interface (if-MIB)
-  - GW (if-MIB)
+  * GW (if-MIB)
-  - Static routes
+  * Static routes
-  - Module/serial (entity-MIB)
+  * Module/serial (entity-MIB)
-  - Cisco support
+  * Cisco support
-  - HP support
+  * HP support
+=== Suggested status monitoring plugins ===
+  * ModuleMon
+=== Implemented plugins ===
+Already implemented plugins can be found on [[devel:ipdevpoll:plugins]]
 ===== Database changes =====
-The following database changes have been suggested FIXME
+The following database changes have been suggested.
+==== Merge swport/gwport tables ====
+A long standing issue has been merging the artificially separated ''swport'' and ''gwport'' tables.  In the SNMP MIBs there is no such divide, both swports and gwports are referred to as interfaces, and IP-MIB can be used to find which interfaces operate on layer 3 (IP).   All interface-generic information should be stored in a single interface table, while specific layer 3 properties should be stored in separate related tables.  There are also many attributes from IF-MIB's ''ifTable'' that are not collected and stored by the current gDD solution, but which would be very interesting to store.
+Most NAV code that deals with interfaces will have duplicate code to take care of ''swport'' and ''gwport''.  Most subsystems only deal with reading from these tables, so during the transition to a new db model one can create ''swport'' and ''gwport'' views.  gDD and networkDiscovery (the topology deriver) are the only known systems that change data in the swport/gwport tables.  networkDiscovery will need a rewrite to support a new model (or update rules need to be added to the new views).
+==== No module requirement for interfaces ====
+The current NAV data model mandates that all gwports/swports bek related to a module.  For netboxes that do not contain physical modules (or whose modules cannot be found by gDD), the current gDD will create an artifical module related to the same device record as the containing netbox and add swports/gwports to this module.
+The IF-MIB has no concept of an interface/module relationship.  Information about such a relationship will most likely come from proprietary MIBs (or possibly a properly populated ENTITY-MIB), and should be treated as a bonus if found.  Ie. NAV's model should add to the interface table a mandatory foreign key to netbox,  and only an optional foreign key into the module table.
-===== Code =====
+===== Status =====
-The mercurial repositories can be found at FIXME
+The first NAV release to include ipdevpoll was version 3.6.
 ===== References =====